Creative Sensemaker: What to read, watch and listen to this weekend

The side profile of a man smoking a cigar

In this week’s Creative Sensemaker, to coincide with Capone arriving on Netflix, Tortoise Media take a look at gangster movies and pick ten essential offerings

By James Oliver

Organised crime is a revolting trade, run by people without scruple or conscience. Its tools are violence and corruption, and it uses them to exploit, degrade and brutalise individuals, communities and sometimes even whole societies. 

But man, does it make for good movies.

Capone, the new Netflix movie with Tom Hardy starring as the most famous mobster of them all, is only the latest proof of this. Gangster films have been thrilling audiences since the 1920s, when American filmmakers started to reflect upon battles over the illegal liquor trade. But the gangster movie boom really began when Wall Street crashed, catching the mood of audiences for whom mobsters weren’t necessarily the worst bad guys – the depression blighting their lives had, after all, been caused by bankers. 

Sure, these flicks were saddled with crime-does-not-pay endings, but there was always something thrilling about their flamboyant characters. They lived high, thumbed their nose at Johnny Law and went out in a blaze of glory. What’s not to like?

It helped, of course, that the main parts were taken by charismatic superstars like James Cagney – a pugnacious firecracker who created a template for movie mobsters that’s still in service to this day.
In each of the films below there’s the same morbid fascination with charismatic bad men doing very bad things – a winning formula since (at least) Richard III.

These films are a vicarious walk on the wild side, a safe way to hang with compellingly bad men without getting hurt. To go back to the Bard: ‘I can smile, and murder whiles I smile.’ That might be an epigram for the genre. 

All of the films listed below are available to rent or buy on demand on Apple, Amazon and other VOD services.

A man whispering in another man's ear


The Godfather (1972)
This list is in no particular order but it makes sense to start with gangsterdom’s most celebrated achievement. Director Francis Ford Coppola turned Mario Puzo’s pulp bestseller into an endlessly watchable epic of generational decay, as the family business passes from sagacious Don Corleone (Marlon Brando) to his cold-blooded son Michael (Al Pacino).

Goodfellas (1990)
Martin Scorsese’s Goodfellas is the punk flip-side to Coppola’s grand opera, a worm’s eye view of mob life. Scorsese knew whereof he spoke: while Coppola was a polite middle-class kid, Scorsese grew up around these people. There’s glamour but no romanticism, just working men doing (dirty) business.

Sometimes (and unfairly) overshadowed by its wonderfully excessive 1980s remake, this Scarface is the best of the early mob movies. Loosely based on the life of Al Capone, it’s an archetypal rise-and-fall story, served up with style and wit by director Howard Hawks.

Battles Without Honour and Humanity (1973)
As the Italians have the Cosa Nostra, so the Japanese have theYakuza. Informed by American mob movies, Battles... is a landmark in Yakuza cinema, set post-war, as returning soldiers seed criminal networks. It builds into a dark, cynical allegory for Japan’s post-war ‘miracle’, something continued across four bitter sequels.

A man sat at a desk

Miller’s Crossing (1990)
While early gangster movies claimed to be ‘ripped from the headlines’, their successors tend to be ripped from other movies. A peerless exercise in pure gangster style, Miller’s Crossing is quite possibly the Coen brothers’ best film, never better than its centrepieces: Albert Finney, a Tommy gun and Danny Boy...

Once Upon A Time In America (1984)
For obvious reasons, Italians are rather ambivalent about potentially eulogising organised crime. So when Sergio Leone came to make this magnificent, essential yet (deeply) flawed mob epic, it was to America that he looked, mythologising the prohibition era as surely as he had the West before it. (Note: also available on Mubi.)

The Untouchables (1987)
After the extravagances of his remake of Scarface, Brian De Palma returned to the genre for this comparatively restrained and altogether more traditional take on the form – a fictionalised re-telling of the fight against Al Capone. But what’s wrong with tradition? Absolutely nothing when it’s as entertaining as this. 

They Made Me A Fugitive (1947)
Britain is sometimes coy about its gangland history, as though organised crime was something only foreigners did. Made in 1947, this film gives the lie to that. While Dad’s Army showed ‘spivs’ as harmless wide boys, here there is brutality galore and pioneering drug dealing. It’s altogether closer to the truth.

A man talking to a policeman over a desk

Eastern Promises (2007)
We hear a lot about ‘Londongrad’ these days, but it’s not just oligarchs moving in: Eastern Promises concerns the Russian mob. It’s not strictly an exposé, however: directed by David Cronenberg, it’s as much anthropology as it is gangster flick, interested not just in crime, but in codes and culture.

The Lavender Hill Mob (1951)
Hoodlums tend to be outsized personalities, so hurrah for The Lavender Hill Mob, a gangster movie for introverts. It’s an Ealing Studios film, with Alec Guinness as the meek little man who conspires to pull off a daring heist. The only film on this list that can truthfully be called ‘delightful’.

Interested in becoming a member?